• Main
  • Understanding Ghadir Khumm
  • Refuting Kitab Al-Ghadir
  • Hadith Gradings
  • Contact us

GhadirKhumm.com - The Full Story

0

Female Narrators

30 Jul 2017
GhadirKhumm.com

Asma’ bint Umais:
No chain Is provided for the hadith of Asma’ bint Umais.

A’isha bint Abi Bakr:
The narration of A’isha solely comes through the path of Ibn Uqda who narrates it with a chain that includes Al-Sari bin Isma’eel. Al-Sari was accused of lying by Yahya Al-Qattan. He was also weakened by Ahmad, Yahya, Abu Hatim, Abu Dawud, Al-Saji, Al-Bazzar, Al-Saji, and Ibn Hibban.

Fatima Al-Zahra’:
The narration of Fatima Al-Zahra’ comes through the path of a group of unknown narrators. However, it seems that the main issue in the hadith is Mohammad bin Al-Hasan bin Al-Hasan Al-Rasheedi who was accused of providing additional chains for weak reports. Refer to his biography in Lisan Al-Mizan. Other paths can be found for the hadith of Fatima in Shia books through the path of Ibn Uqda, however, they are weak according to both Sunni and Shia standards.

Fatima bint Hamza:
No chain is provided for the hadith of Fatima bint Hamza.

Um Salama:
The narration of Um Salama can only be found through the path of Ibn Uqda. However, this report is disconnected which makes it unreliable.

Um Hani’:
The narration of Um Hani’ can only be found through the path of Ibn Uqda. However, this report is disconnected which makes it unreliable.

Conclusion: There are no reliable narrations in this section.

Social Share

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

*
*

captcha *

Recent Posts

  • Thaqalayn – A Critical Study
  • The Shia Version of Hadith Al-Ghadir
  • Al-Amini’s Response to the Sunni View
  • Did Sunni Scholars Agree with the Shia Interpretation?

At GhadirKhumm.com we aim to provide readers with the correct understanding of the events at Ghadir Khumm by providing the context and explaining the meaning of:

“Of whomsoever I am his mawla, Ali, is his mawla.”

© 2017 - GhadirKhumm.com